Steve Saunders Goldwing Forums banner
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 7 of 29 Posts

· Premium Member
Joined
·
2,380 Posts
imported post

alanz wrote:
I have a '88 GL1500 and some time ago I fitted a 4 degree trigger wheel. It felt like it made a difference at low revs to help the hesitation that the early 1500's were prone to. However, recently I have noticed that it is preigniting (pinking, or pinging - depends where you come form), even from 3000 revs in top gear if I give it a reasonable amount of throttle. I am sure it wasn't like that when I first installed the trigger wheel and I even think it is getting worse. The minimum octane we can purchase here is 91 and that is what I have been using.
I can easily change it back to the original trigger wheel but I don't really think that is the problem. Can anyone suggest another reason for the ignition being overly advanced on acceleration.
Alanz, it could be many things from the bike running a little hotter, to a little carbon build up in the combustion chambers, to some wear on the cam parts, to somevarnish plugging of the carb intermediate jets, to a fuel volatility problem.. Maybe that 4° timing wheel is just too much advance for your bike.

I'm not sure where your fuel comes from, or how it's refined for summer & winter usage but here in the US our fuel is blended differently for different seasons with the winter blend having a much higher vapor pressure (that starts easier in cold weather).. Do to the hurricane damage in New Orleans the government here in the US has allowed some of the winter blend to be sold this summer to alleviate the high fuel prices & lack of availability.. If that same fuel has found it's way to your area it will spark knock like crazy in hot weather if your spark advance is close to max or your compression is a little higher than normal.

There is also the possibility that what youare buying as 92 octane isn't really 92as stated & has been mixed with regular to either make more profit or because the 92 wasn't available at the time..

Twisty
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
2,380 Posts
imported post

alanz wrote:
Thanks guys,

Looks like it is getting closer and closer to having to take one of the heads off for a look. Obviously want to leave that as a last resort.

Will try to see if our GM dealers carry the Top Cleaner that Vic is talking about.

Cheers

Al
Al, before going into it too far just run a compression check.. If it runs to the high side of specs (or higher)for your altitude then maybe you have a carbon problem.. If it is near the mid to low end of specs than I doubt you have much carbon build up.. Be sure it is warm & the throttle is open a ways to get a good test..

Have you tried a different brand of premium gasoline yet?

How about replacing the fuel filter? If it is plugging the carbs will run a bit lean under full power..

Twisty
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
2,380 Posts
imported post

alanz wrote:
Twisty,

Thanks for your advice also. I was thinking about the compression test but I will have to try and source a compression gauge that will fit down the hole. Mind you if it is carbon, it may only be a hot spot rather than over-compression. Is that possible or am I oversimplifying it?

Your comment about the fuel filter has also just rung a bell. I record all my fuel consumption figures and at about the time when this pinging got really noticeable I noted that the fuel consumption had jumped from 40 mpg (Imperial) to 44 mpg. This was basically from one tank to the next and I was patting myself on the back because I thought it was my skillful driving that was saving me some gas. I have since put about 6 tanks of gas through and they have all been about the same even when I took it for a bit of a blast to try to clean it out.

I will see if I can get a replacement one and check it out.

Will let you know how I get on in the next day or two.
Al, if you are not showing any carbon deposits on the spark plugs I doubt you have enough carbon in those cylinders to have carbon hot spots.. Carbon hot spots also usually doesn't give you initial accel spark knock but shows itself as a knock aftera hard workout like climbing a hill or after a while ona long acceleration.

Your problem sounds more like either the fuel in your area has changed, or for some reason you are now running a little leaner than you were.

If you aren't burning any oil (it doesn't take much to produce carbon), aren't using any fuel additives like MMO,& are using unleaded fuel I doubt you have much carbon build-up..

Anybody in your area have a bikedyno with a fuel/air sniffer that works? If so, just have them run your bike at 4th & 5h gear throttleroll ons & check the fuel/air ratio..

If you haven't changed that fuel filter in a while that might be a good place to start.

Have you called your local fuel inspection or whoever controls the fuel quality & measurement in your area to see if something has changed in the fuel supply in your area?

Twisty
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
2,380 Posts
imported post

alanz wrote:
I've had a 'look' at my vaccuum hoses and they seem to be ok, however, that is only the ones that I can see. As everyone, here, knows they go all over the place and you can't check them all until you pull the bike apart. I will add it to my list. I realise this is going to take some time.

You are right about the supply of parts. The Gold Wing is not the most common bike over here and the parts supply is not good and very expensive. I tend to buy from the US over the Internet but that can take a bit of time.

The cost of fuel here is NZ$1.52 = CAN$1.21 = US$1.03.

So that actually compares pretty well with your prices. We thought we were hard done by because the prices have skyrocketed. Guess it is happening everywhere.
Al, formulating a list is great way to work your way through your problem.. I'm not sure why Vic thinks you are "running around like a chicken with his head cut off" butthat is his opinion not mine. It sounds like you have a good planof action & you are asking plenty of questions so should have a good idea where to look & what to check.

Can you think back to when the problem started? Was anything added or changed around that time? No chance you added a free flowing air filter or something similar?

Is this only a 3000 RPM acceleration problem? Or do you get in in all gears at different RPM roll on's?

Here's something to check into,, the 1200 Wing uses an input to the ign box to allow 4th & 5th gears to use a vacuum signal to control spark instead of a fixed spark curve.. I can't tell you if the 1500 uses the same type system or not.. Maybe someone with a 1500 manual or that has researched the 1500 spark control can shed some light here. IF, your bike has such a system & theign system doesn't see a 4th or 5th gear signal you wouldn't get much spark retard on acceleration in the top gears. (kind of just tossing this out here as I have no idea if the 1500 has such a system or not)..

Twisty
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
2,380 Posts
imported post

Goldwinger1984 wrote:
twisty wrote:
alanz wrote:
I've had a 'look' at my vaccuum hoses and they seem to be ok, however, that is only the ones that I can see. As everyone, here, knows they go all over the place and you can't check them all until you pull the bike apart. I will add it to my list. I realise this is going to take some time.

You are right about the supply of parts. The Gold Wing is not the most common bike over here and the parts supply is not good and very expensive. I tend to buy from the US over the Internet but that can take a bit of time.

The cost of fuel here is NZ$1.52 = CAN$1.21 = US$1.03.

So that actually compares pretty well with your prices. We thought we were hard done by because the prices have skyrocketed. Guess it is happening everywhere.
Al, formulating a list is great way to work your way through your problem.. I'm not sure why Vic thinks you are "running around like a chicken with his head cut off" butthat is his opinion not mine. It sounds like you have a good planof action & you are asking plenty of questions so should have a good idea where to look & what to check.

Can you think back to when the problem started? Was anything added or changed around that time? No chance you added a free flowing air filter or something similar?

Is this only a 3000 RPM acceleration problem? Or do you get in in all gears at different RPM roll on's?

Here's something to check into,, the 1200 Wing uses an input to the ign box to allow 4th & 5th gears to use a vacuum signal to control spark instead of a fixed spark curve.. I can't tell you if the 1500 uses the same type system or not.. Maybe someone with a 1500 manual or that has researched the 1500 spark control can shed some light here. IF, your bike has such a system & theign system doesn't see a 4th or 5th gear signal you wouldn't get much spark retard on acceleration in the top gears. (kind of just tossing this out here as I have no idea if the 1500 has such a system or not)..

Twisty
Twisty, since you questionedthe statement I made about running around like a chicken with its head cut off, I just want you to know that itdoes not solely apply to you. I manage, moderate and am Senior Guru at several Gold Wing sites and in my experience I see a lot of misdirection on the parts of well meaning people who genuinely like to help or simply seek to outdo others with the knowledge they think is correct. All of their input is greatly appreciated but not always accurate. In fact I even screw up occasionally, but, I'm not ever afraid to acknowledge and correct my mistakes so that others will have the appropriate facts available to them.

Steve Saunders and I are slowly working towards creating a special section on this site that will contain only 99.9% accurate information regarding Gold Wing specs and maintenance, but, until that comes to fruition I'llneed to make corrections here.

Now don't get offended and please remember that it was me who recomended you for Guru title herebut, this line of your post is the type of misleadingthing that I'm speaking of; Twisty said: "IF, your bike has such a system & theign system doesn't see a 4th or 5th gear signal you wouldn't get much spark retard on acceleration in the top gears.

Yourstatement is not accurate and could create a lot of confusion for a guy working on his Wing for the first time. Your statement could really mislead someone and cause them to spend hours of diagnostic time for no reason and may even persuade them to replace parts that don't need to be replaced.

Maybe you're just exhausted after a hard day and posted the wrong facts, but, still the facts you posted might be believed by some unsuspecting newbie who trusts your Guru title and writing style. To me, that gives this site a bad name because the information proves to be unreliable and I try to work real hard at keepingmaintenance and repair facts accurateon this site.

Perhaps what you meant to state is that the Gold Wing vacuum advance system advances (it does not retard)the ignition timing 11.5 degrees when the gear shift switch is closedin 4th or 5th gear and there is at least 1.2 -2.0 inches of intake manifold vacuum. The internal electronic advancecurve begins at 1500 RPM and gives atotal 33.5 degrees of advance at 3200 RPM. From these facts and using a timing light one could accurately check the ignition timing advance system accurately and be secure in the knowledge that the system is performing correctly as designed. Using your instructions a guy could be running around like a chicken with his head cut off trying to figure why his bike doesn't work right.

Keep up the good work here Twisty, but let's try to get it right as much as possible so we don't have people sayingthey got the wrong info from that so and so Steve Saunders site.


Vic
"Now don't get offended and please remember that it was me who recomended you for Guru title" you already know my feeling on this one..

Vic, you already know how I feel about this Guru thing.. I flat don't give a S-h-i-t!!! I'm not here for the fame or money like a lot of you folks are.. I am here spending my time for ONE REASON ONLY, that is to help fellow Wingers as much as I am able to.



Vic wrote:
Perhaps what you meant to state is that the Gold Wing vacuum advance system advances (it does not retard)
I'm sorry I misunderstood how that system works & didn't realize it could DEFY the laws of physics & advance the spark only. If that's the case why even bother with a vacuum system as once it sees vacuum (EVEN ONCE) the spark would be advanced for the life of the bike.

Right from the manual: "The ignition control unit electronically varies the ignition timing in relation to engine speed when the transmission is in 1st through 3rd gears. When the transmission is in 4th or 5th gear the gearshift sensor informs the ignition control unit and the ignition timing is varied electronically in relation to engine vacuum"

Twisty
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
2,380 Posts
imported post

Vic, then you are sayingAls 1500 does use the same 4th- 5th gear vacuum system as the 1200 used. (Just trying to make sure you are both talking about the same bike here).

Twisty
 
1 - 7 of 29 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top